!LOLZ 😄 - Interesting table, but we have to correct you.
The first two scenarios are possible. (The second one, only if all 200 tokens that we initially put on sale were bought by one member at the very beginning and held all the way through.)

The last three scenarios (3rd, 4th, and 5th) are not possible, or better to say, not yet possible.
In other words, those three scenarios might be possible when more tokens are issued and sold, and if all the things that influence growth on the Hive blockchain keep rolling, more or less the same as they were by now.

So, it is not impossible, but you have to consider that every purchase has its own starting point from which those two years (four or five) are calculated to show the same or similar result as in your table.

For instance, you made 17 different purchases (16 from us and one from the market) at different times, in different amounts, and for different prices. Your oldest purchase was about two years ago, while the most recent one was just a few days ago.
Therefore, your cumulative overall performance (profit/gain or loss) would look entirely different from the "picture" of the member above.

On the other hand, if we observe each purchase separately, then you'll have 17 different scenarios so far. The first (2-year-old) purchase would show the same result as from the member above, while the last one (from a few days ago) would be at total zero (or complete loss) until the next reward payout, and the remaining 15 purchases, more or less, somewhere in between.

However, we agree with you that...

"...the bigger numbers show the same case in a different light."

😃

!ALIVE | !LOLZ