Looks like the work of 119 upvotes and one big downvote. That's stake-based voting for you. Seems there is a contingent that thinks giveaways are bad for Hive somehow. I've yet to see a good explanation for why that doesn't come down to "they make more than they give away."
If it is always considered bad to earn more than one invests, or to take profits, then Hive has no redeeming value.