Sardine Scam or Delicious Novelty?

in Proof of Brain15 hours ago

20250512_175336~2.jpg

I buy sardines quite a bit at home. I often eat them for lunch on weekends. They are a good source of protein, calcium and omega 3 fatty acids. They are healthy, easy and I have a brand that I actually like the taste of.

20250512_175406~2.jpg

When we were traveling in the Azores we came across a novelty sardines store in the city of Ponta Delgada. I'm pretty sure that its a franchise chain of stores, because I've seen these shops in other parts of Europe, specifically in Mainland Portugal. There is one in the city of Lisbon, if I'm remembering correctly.

20250512_175427~2.jpg

The store sells an assortment of different sardines and canned seafood products in colorful trendy packaging. They were, of course, being sold for very exorbitant prices as well. It is clearly a store that caters to tourists and is marketed as a novelty gift shop. Sardines and canned fish to bring home from vacation, for friends or family or oneself. I don't get the impression that this is a store that locals frequent often for their regular sardines meals. They are just too expensive to be practical. The shop sells tins of lobster and I think the most expensive even had gold flakes in it. Again, these are very clearly a novelty item.

20250512_175359~2.jpg

Question: At what price tag do sardines become a scam do you think?

So anyway, I got suckered into buying a tin. The assortment of colorful marketing. How could I resist? I got a bit of sticker shock when I saw how much they were but after humming and hawing about it for a while, and some encouragement from my wife, I decided to just go for it. Give them a go for fun. What the hell.

I went with the most basic option of simple sardines. I wanted to try the most basic to really get a sense if these were anything better than what I normally buy at the grocery store. They were also the cheapest option.

20250512_173007~2.jpg

So what do you think they cost me? Any guesses?

20250512_175421~2.jpg

Well I paid €15 Euro for one single can of sardines!

To put that into perspective the sardines that I buy at the grocery store cost $3.99 regular price and $3.29 on sale.

1000018059.jpg

Those are CAD prices also, which is approximately €2.49 to €2.03 euro!

So to reverse the pricing into CAD to make a proper comparison the vacation sardines cost me $24.32 CAD which is 8x more expensive then the grocery store variety!! Or around that I think.

But look at the fancy packaging they wrapped them in... worth it right??..

20250511_185706~2.jpg

So I ended up eating these for lunch one day on that same trip. It was a way to recoup some of their cost. I didn't need to buy extra food that day at a restaurant. I will admit, they were very good. They weren't fishy at all and I would go as far to say that they were probably the best sardines that I've ever tried. I have probably only tried 3 or 4 different brands and varieties of sardines though, so take that with a grain of salt. Even though they were the best sardines that I've ever had, the enjoyment that I got from them was not 8x more than my normal grocery store variety. For that reason, my final judgement is that these are not worth the hefty price tag and are therefore a scam. Albeit a delicious one. I'd call them a low risk scam overall, but a scam nonetheless.

1000018060.jpg

What do you think about that price? Are they worth it? Do you think that these sardines are a scam or a fun novelty vacation souvenir? Let me know your thoughts in the comments.

Sort:  



This post has been shared on Reddit by @theworldaroundme through the HivePosh initiative.

Haha, wow, this is exactly how we get tricked by capitalism. 😅

But those tins are beautiful and really attractive, but I bet the sardines taste exactly the same as the plain cheap ones.

It’s funny how packaging and branding can completely change how something feels if we dont think further, And OMG the price jump, lol.

Yes its true. Good marketing goes a long way in terms of influencing our perception. They were good but not proportional to the crazy price.

They looks nice though

Thanks for sharing. :)

😃

Haha! I went to a shop exactly like that in Porto and nearly fell for the scam. The one in Porto had cans of sardines for every year, great trick to get people buy their own birth year.

Yes, this one had that too! If you zoom into the very first picture you can see the dates on the tins. I should have mentioned that because its a trick, like you said.

I think that its the same shop as you were at. I'm pretty sure its a franchise amd there are locatjons all over Portugal and maybe Europe. I saw the same shop in Lisbon I think, but it actually might have been Porto.

All in all, its a cool idea but the prices were insane when you think about what you're buying. I guess it works on some people... like me 😅😆

But then, I tried it so that others don't have to I suppose haha

🤷‍♂️

Thanks for taking one for the team 😂

Just checked my photos, yeah definitely the same franchise
1000056118.jpg

According to early episodes of Futurama that sounds like a steal!

Lmao 😂
I haven't seen that episode (or don't remember it) but was able to look it up. Extinct anchovies $50 million! Lol.
I guess my sardines were indeed a steal.

oh lol, it may have been achovies yeah, my memory's not the best :D

Anchovies. sardines
Its close enough. Both salted small fish in a tin haha. still fitting for the joke lol